Disability FAQs: “How Can I Get More Money?”

We’ve gotten a ton of emails from readers basically asking the same disability question: “How can I get more money?” Today, we’ll provide detailed answers for every scenario people asked us about below.

“Can I Get My Disability Reevaluated, Then Receive More Money?”

Unfortunately, no. The reason why is simple: Your disability payments aren’t based on your diagnosis, or which health condition(s) you have. You can’t get paid more money because your symptoms got worse, or for any other medical reason. If you’re approved for Social Security disability insurance (SSDI) benefits, how much you earned while working determines your payment amount. Here’s how the formula works:

  1. The Social Security Administration (SSA) averages your highest monthly paychecks earned over your work history. However, you must have worked full-time and paid FICA taxes for 5 in the last 10 years before becoming disabled.
  2. Then, they adjust that monthly paycheck amount for current inflation.
  3. Your monthly SSDI payment equals a percentage of that final amount. In most cases, it’s 40% of your highest average monthly paycheck earned while working.

However, the percentage you get paid in disability benefits isn’t always exactly 40%. It depends on whether your wages were lower than average, about average, or higher than average for any given year. For example: In 2018, the average wage index amount was $52,145.80. If your annual salary was $30,000 in 2018, your SSDI payment should equal closer to 75% of your monthly paycheck. But if you earned $90,000, your SSDI payment could be as little as 27% of your average monthly paycheck. The SSA uses an identical formula to calculate who gets paid more money (or less) in retirement benefits based on these percentages.



“If I Was Approved for SSI, Can I Get More Money If More Things Are Wrong With Me?”

This is a slightly different question since the person asked specifically about SSI, or Supplemental Security Income. SSI is traditionally referred to as “welfare,” and the payments come directly out of the federal government’s general tax fund. If you haven’t worked recently or enough years to qualify for SSDI, then you may get SSI disability. Unlike SSDI, the government doesn’t use your past work earnings to calculate your SSI payment. Instead, nearly all people on SSI get paid the maximum monthly amount. In 2020, the max SSI payment any individual can receive is $783; for eligible couples, it’s $1,157.

However, this reader says she gets just $522 in monthly SSI and needs more money to live on. That’s likely because SSI benefits automatically qualify you for Medicaid health coverage. So, her SSI payment shows how much her state deducts to cover her monthly Medicaid premiums. Unfortunately, it’s impossible to get more money in SSI benefits based on your health condition or symptoms. However, many states pay additional cash to SSI recipients on top of their federal payments.

“How Do I Get Approved For More Money? What Has To Be Happening To Someone To Get More Money?”

Honestly, there are just a few ways to get more money each month once you’re on disability. One involves working and paying more Social Security taxes (also known as FICA taxes). Once you qualify for SSDI, your health problems may improve enough for you to start working again in time. But you don’t have to give up your benefits just to try working part-time or at home.

Instead, the SSA’s Ticket to Work program specifically helps disability recipients like you re-enter the job market. That program gives you all the resources you need to ease back into working part-time or even work from home. You can work for up to nine months before deciding whether you can handle full-time jobs again. But if you try to sneak around and work to earn income without notifying the SSA first, they’ll end your benefits immediately.

Your second way to get more money is through each year’s approved cost-of-living-adjustment increase. The federal government announces each year’s COLA increase in October, which goes into effect the following January. For 2020, this year’s COLA increase was 1.6%; in 2019, it was 2.8%. Any veteran, SSDI or SSI recipient automatically gets a raise that’s equal to that percentage amount. In other words, if your disability payment’s $1,000 in December 2018, it becomes $1,028 in January 2019 and $1,044.50 in January 2020. However, the federal government doesn’t guarantee a COLA increase every calendar year.

“My Brother-in-Law’s Disability Went Up In April, Mine Didn’t. Did I Do Something Wrong?”

A third way to get more money each month involves the SSA’s twice-yearly AERO recalculation of benefits. This happens every March and October, and the SSA uses your state and federal income tax information to do this. Basically, when you apply for SSD, they look at your previous year’s earnings and the year before you became disabled. You might mistakenly submit incomplete income information or other things that result in a lower payment than you deserve. If you’re owed more money than you currently get, then they’ll increase your disability benefits automatically.

Another reason why some people’s payments appear to increase randomly throughout the year? Because of things like the workers’ compensation offset. If you’re hurt on the job and qualify for workers’ comp due to a serious, life-altering injury, disability comes next. Let’s say you are in a major trucking accident and must surrender your commercial driver’s license (CDL). Your doctor says you need a series of back surgeries before you can drive safely again for long distances. If your workers’ compensation runs out after disability begins, your first few SSD payments will be lower. For example: You get $500/month in workers’ comp and $1,000/month in SSD for half a year. Once workers’ comp payments end, your SSD amount goes up to $1,500/month. This higher SSD payment reflects the amount originally “offset” by your workers’ compensation benefits.

“I Split My Time Between Michigan & California. Does My State Matter for Getting Disability? Which One Pays More Money?”

Yes! Five U.S. states have programs that pay short-term or temporary disability benefits to residents:

  • California
  • Hawaii
  • New Jersey
  • New York
  • Rhode Island

These payments typically last no more than 6-12 months, depending on which state you live in. If you need more money and already get federal disability, then you likely qualify for these programs, too.

You May Qualify for Legal Assistance

Thinking about applying for disability benefits? Having an experienced Social Security attorney file your claim makes you 2x more likely to get benefits approved on your first try. Since these lawyers always work on contingency, you can get a free, no-obligation consultation and get advice for your specific situation. This consultation starts with a phone call, and you don’t have to move forward with your claim. If you don’t get a cash settlement, you owe the lawyer $0. And if you do win, you’ll only pay a small, one-time fee.

Ready to see if you may qualify? Click the button below to start your free online benefits evaluation now!

Get Your Free Benefits Evaluation